scotch recipe caribbean mushrooms
News

A Great Caribbean Mushroom Recipe

By: Caribbean Journal Staff - November 7, 2019

By Nigel Spence

Mushrooms are generally not high on the list of foods that Caribbean folks hold in high regard. That may be because we are not and have never been a mushroom growing or consuming society.

What I was taught when growing up was that mushrooms were poisonous and should be avoided at all costs lest you touch it, keel over and meet your Maker. As I got older the only other mushrooms ever encountered were of the hallucinogenic variety and those too came with tales of going over to the dark side, never to return to normal.

Needless to say, with all these dark tales, there was absolutely no reason for me to further explore the possibilities of mushrooms being a part of my diet.

Then came the girlfriend.

She was Italian, with a good dose of crazy, and quite opinionated.

Among the many firsts I experienced with her, one that I can mention is the introduction to EATING mushrooms.

It was love at first bite (the mushrooms, that is).

It was that savory satisfying food that I didn’t know I needed in my life, unlike the girlfriend who had to move on to someone more in keeping with her character, because at that time it just wasn’t me.

I do thank her for the introduction as it has turned out to be a “happily ever after” story with the fearsome fungus my mom always warned me about.

Mushrooms don’t need a lot of in-depth preparation for it to be awesome; sometimes the simpler the better.

SCOTCH BONNET MUSHROOMS

1  LB SHIITAKE MUSHROOMS, FRESH

2 TABLESPOONS ITALIAN PARSLEY, CHOPPED

1 TEASPOON SCOTCH BONNET SALT (RECIPE FOLLOWS)

¼ CUP EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL

METHOD:

REMOVE STEMS FROM MUSHROOMS AND DISCARD. HEAT OLIVE OIL IN LARGE SKILLET OVER MEDIUM HEAT. PLACE MUSHROOMS BROWN SIDE DOWN IN SKILLET. LET MUSHROOMS SIT AND SAUTE IN THE OIL WITHOUT MOVING THEM FOR ABOUT 4 MINUTES. TURN OVER TO THE SIDE WITH THE GILLS AND COOK FOR AN ADDITIONAL 2 MINUTES.

REMOVE TO A LARGE BOWL AND TOSS IN SCOTCH BONNET BUTTER AND CHOPPED PARSLEY.

SERVE WARM AS A SIDE DISH OR ADD AS A FILLING TO OMELETTES,  TO PERK UP A WARM SALAD OR TO ADD A NEW DIMENSION TO POTATO SALAD.

SCOTCH BONNET SALT

Ingredients

20 Whole Fresh Scotch Bonnet Peppers roughly chopped

1/2 Cup coarse Kosher Salt (or sea salt)

1 Large Mortar & Pestle (or food processor)

Method:

Put both ingredients in mortar and pestle and pound until it is the texture of a chunky paste.

Work in batches if your mortar and pestle is not big enough to hold everything at once.

Nigel Spence, a Culinary Institute of America alumnus, was born in Kingston, Jamaica. Nigel freelanced at the Television Food Network for 3 years where he worked with culinary luminaries such as Bobby Flay and Emeril Lagasse. Chef Spence has appeared twice on Throwdown with Bobby Flay where he emerged the victor in cook offs against the Food Network star and was featured on CBS when he appeared on Tony’s Table as well as ABC’s Neighborhood Eats, NBC’s The Today Show , Sirius’ Everyday Living with Martha Stewart and TVFN’s Chopped. The acclaimed and New York Times-reviewed Ripe Kitchen and Bar is Mr Spence’s first entrepreneurial endeavour.

Popular Posts eagle beach cj photo

Aruba’s New Adults-Only Resort Has Swim-Up Suites, a Rooftop Bar and One of the World’s Greatest Beaches 

Eagle Beach. If you know Aruba, you know it. That wide, white, shimmering stretch of sand in the northwestern corner of the island is one of our favorite beaches in the Caribbean — and inarguably among the best beaches, well, anywhere […]


This Iconic British Virgin Islands Resort Is Finally Back, With New Rooms and Five Jaw-Dropping Beaches 

peter island is back

This beach gets its name from the island across the water. Centuries ago, some of Blackbeard’s crew tried to make the crossing from Dead Chest Island, and, well, this beach got a name of its own: Deadman’s.  If you’ve been […]


This Uncrowded Caribbean island Has Picture-Perfect Beaches, Countless Sandbars and the World’s Most Beautiful Water 

exuma caribbean island

It’s hard to see where the water ends and the sky begins. I’m wading on a sugar-white sandbar in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean, with nothing around but turquoise-tinted clouds. There are shades of blue here I’ve never seen. […]


Related Posts st croix carambola

Why You Need to Visit St Croix in the US Virgin Islands This Christmas 

It’s the biggest, best Christmas party in the Caribbean: Crucian Christmas, the legendary annual festival on St Croix in the US Virgin Islands. It’s a weeklong celebration that towers over every other holiday party in the region — and it’s […]


Caribbean Photo of the Week: On the Beach in Tulum, Mexico

tulum caribbean photo hilton

The latest Caribbean Photo comes from Caribbean Journal reader Marcus Weitzman, who sent in this very pretty shot of the beach at his hotel in Tulum. Have you taken a great photo in the Caribbean? Send it to news@caribjournal.com with […]


Riu Just Reopened Its Negril, Jamaica All-Inclusive With New Swim-Up Rooms 

jamaica riu all-inclusive

If you’ve been to an all-inclusive in the Caribbean, it’s likely you’ve seen one: the swim-up room, that sought-after amenity that lets you slide open your patio door and walk right down the steps into a pool. Sometimes it’s your […]