Key West First Legal Rum Distillery It’s not just a tourist attraction. This Key West institution makes a hearty portfolio of rums, led by the rum that started it all, the “Key West First Legal Rum,” an exceptionally brash rum with a sweet edge. Now, KWFLRD even makes its own “cuban coffee” rum infused with coffee beans aged in rum barrels and a cask-strength “105 Simonton Rum.”